Hadith 38

Hadith 38

Narrated by Abu Hurayrah (RA) · Bukhari

Arabic Text

English Translation

— Abu Hurayrah (RA) (Bukhari)

Commentary

Walī Allah is reached through the obligatory first, then voluntary on top. Not through dance, music, or invented practices.

Extended Explanation

The path to walī-status (closeness to Allah) — explicitly defined. First, the obligatory acts. Then the voluntary, which take one progressively closer until ‘I become his hearing, his seeing, his hand, his foot’ (i.e., Allah guides every faculty toward what pleases Him).

Ibn Rajab and Ibn Taymiyyah use this hadith to refute innovated paths to walāyah: dancing, music, communing with graves, special initiations. The Prophet ﷺ defined the path: obligations first, then voluntary acts. Anyone claiming walī-status by another route is making a claim against the explicit text.

From the Scholars

"‘I become his hearing…’ does NOT mean Allah indwells in the body — it means Allah guides the limbs of the walī to be used only in His obedience. The Sūfī interpretation of ittiḥād (union) is rejected."

Ibn Rajab · Jāmi‘ al-‘Ulūm wa al-Ḥikam

"The walī of Allah is whoever fulfils the obligatory and avoids the prohibited — that is the bare minimum of walāyah. Adding the voluntary lifts him in rank."

Ibn Taymiyyah

Fiqh & Rulings

  • Walāyah of Allah is open to every Muslim who fulfils the obligatory and avoids the prohibited.
  • Obligatory acts come BEFORE voluntary — emphasising voluntary while neglecting obligatory is a deception.
  • Hostility to a walī = hostility to Allah (‘I have declared war on him’) — a terrifying threat that includes mocking, persecuting, or harming the righteous.
  • Neither walī-status nor karāmāt (miracles) make one infallible — every walī is still bound by sharī‘ah.

Qur'ān Cross-References

10:62-63‘Indeed, the awliyā’ of Allah — no fear shall come upon them, nor shall they grieve. Those who believed and used to fear Allah.’ — the Qur’ānic definition of walī.
5:54‘…a people He loves and they love Him.’

Key Arabic Vocabulary

وَلِيًّاwaliyyan

a close friend / ally

آذَنْتُهُādhantuhu

I declared (war)

النَّوَافِلِan-nawāfil

voluntary acts

أُحِبَّهُuḥibbahu

I love him

Today's Reflection

Are your obligatory acts solid before you focus on extras?

Key Benefits

  • 1The path to closeness is open — but ordered.
  • 2Love of Allah is earned through obedience, not invention.

Common Mistakes & Warnings

  • Anyone claiming to be a ‘walī’ while neglecting obligatory ṣalāh, fasting, hijab, or halal earnings is contradicting the very definition.
  • The phrase ‘I become his hearing…’ is metaphorical — guidance and tawfīq, NOT divine indwelling. The latter (ḥulūl) is kufr.
  • Karāmāt are real but rare — and not the criterion of walāyah. Many awliyā’ have no karāmāt; many fakers fake karāmāt.

Related Hadiths

Memorization Progress